Well, I ended up buying both of them, and one of them is so awesome for fish photos, I just wanted to tell you guys about it. (the other is so great for general photography, I just have to keep it too

It is the Canon A630. It is an 8mp camera with "excellent" image quality, and tons of great features.
The features I like the most are, the tilt and twist screen, which allows you to take photos of yourself, with your fish, and to see yourself holding the fish, while your doing it, for easy line up.
Also, it uses "easy to find AA batts". Rechargeables are great, but don't have as long a shelf life as regular alkalines. No matter which you go with, always carry a set of Alkalines for a back up.
Finally (and this feature is absolutely the coolest) this camera will allow you to tweak everything just the way you like it... flash level, focus distance, ISO, shutter speed, self timing length, and number of shots after the count... everything ! Then, you simply hit "save settings" in custom mode "C".
So, the next time I'm out on the water, and stick a pig, I break out the tripod, attach the camera, and turn it on (in "C" mode). Grab the fish out of the livewell, and hit the shutter button. Bam ! It remembers "everything I have it programmed for" ! So it counts to 6 seconds (or up to 30), then takes 3 shots (or up to 10).
Anyway, here it is: http://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/A630/A630A.HTM
.....and you can get one for only about $200 ! A freaking steal, for what it is ! Yes, I have other cameras that will work, but I like this one so much, I'm buying another one of these for a back up, this week !

Here's a couple shots from my new Canon A630

This was a little Northern Pike from Lake Davis last week. All gone in a few more....

Oh, and although not as nice for self-taken fish shots, my new Fuji S6000fd is a fine camera for general photography.... (without taking the full plunge into dSLR's..... which I would, if I wasn't a poor man)
I took these yesterday morning at Bodega Bay.


Peace,
Fish
PS, If anyone buys an A630, just let me know, and I will tell you all of my settings (for a starting point), and how to save them in the cameras preset "C" mode.